Repair Guides

Torsion vs Extension Spring Replacement: Which System Does Your Door Have?

Every sectional garage door in London uses one of two spring systems, and which one you have changes the repair, the cost, the safety cables you should be looking for, and how long the next set will last. Telling them apart takes thirty seconds from the doorway. Here is how, and what follows from the answer.

Torsion and extension garage door spring replacement in London Ontario
5yr
labour warranty
60–90min
Typical arrival in London
24/7
Same-day & emergency
Flat
Upfront pricing
⚡ Quick answer

Look at where the springs sit. A torsion spring is a single heavy spring mounted on a steel shaft directly above the door opening. Extension springs are two lighter springs stretched along the horizontal tracks, one on each side. Torsion is the modern standard: it lasts 15,000–20,000 cycles against roughly 10,000 for extension, controls the door more smoothly, and is safer when it fails. Replacement in London runs $200–$350 for torsion and $170–$280 for a pair of extension springs. Neither is a DIY job.

How to tell whether you have torsion or extension springs

Stand inside the garage with the door closed and look up. That is the whole test.

Identifying your garage door spring system
Look forTorsion systemExtension system
Where the spring sitsOn a steel shaft directly above the door openingAlong the horizontal tracks, one each side
How many springsOne on most single doors, two on most double doorsAlways two — one per side
Spring diameterThick, 2 to 2.75 inches, tightly woundThinner, 1 to 1.5 inches, loosely coiled
CablesWind onto drums at each end of the shaftRun through pulleys at the end of each spring
Safety cableNot requiredRequired — runs through the centre of each spring
Movement when the door opensSpring unwinds in place on the shaftSprings visibly contract along the track
Typical vintage in LondonMost doors installed after about 1995Older installs and lighter single doors

If you can see a horizontal steel bar spanning the width of the opening with a spring wrapped around it, that is torsion. If the space above the door is empty and there are two springs running back over the car, that is extension.

Torsion spring replacement above a garage door in London Ontario
Torsion: one shaft, one or two springs, cable drums at each end. Everything happens above the opening.

One more thing worth checking while you are looking up: on an extension system, trace each spring and confirm there is a steel cable threaded through the middle of it, anchored at both ends. That is the containment cable, and it is what stops a snapped spring from crossing the garage at speed. Missing containment cables are common on older London installs and are cheap to add — see our safety inspection guide for the full check.

How torsion and extension springs actually work

Both systems exist to do the same job: store enough energy to offset the weight of the door so the opener only has to overcome friction. They go about it in opposite ways.

Torsion — twisting energy

A torsion spring is wound around a shaft that runs above the opening. As the door lowers, the cables pull on drums at each end of that shaft and wind the spring tighter, storing energy through torsion — twist. When you open the door, the spring unwinds and turns the shaft, the drums wind the cables back on, and the door is lifted by that stored torque. Because both cables come off the same shaft, the two sides of the door are mechanically forced to move together. That is why torsion doors run straighter and rarely go out of square.

Extension spring replacement along garage door tracks in London Ontario
Extension: two springs stretched along the horizontal tracks. The safety cable through the centre is not optional.

Extension — stretching energy

Extension springs work by simple elongation. Each spring is anchored at the back of the horizontal track and connected through a pulley to a cable that runs down to the bottom bracket of the door. Closing the door stretches the springs; opening it lets them contract and pull the door up. Cheaper to manufacture, simpler to install, and entirely independent of one another — which is exactly the weakness. If one side ages faster than the other, the door starts lifting crooked, and a crooked door is how rollers come out of tracks. Our track repair page covers where that ends up.

Why the failure modes differ

When a torsion spring breaks, it does so on the shaft, contained by the shaft itself. There is a loud bang, the door becomes far too heavy, and that is the extent of it. When an unrestrained extension spring breaks, it is a stretched steel coil releasing along the length of the garage — which is precisely why containment cables became standard. Either way the door is unsafe to operate afterwards, and either way our broken spring replacement guide covers what happens next.

Torsion vs extension springs: the honest comparison

Torsion wins on nearly every measure that matters over the life of a door. Extension wins on upfront cost, and on doors light enough that the difference in control does not show. Here is the whole picture.

Torsion vs extension garage door springs compared
MeasureTorsionExtension
Rated cycle life15,000 – 20,000 (high-cycle to 50,000)8,000 – 10,000
Typical service life10 – 15 years6 – 10 years
Door controlBoth sides forced to move togetherSides can drift out of sync
NoiseQuieter, smoother travelLouder, more bounce at the floor
Safety on failureContained by the shaftNeeds a containment cable, or it becomes a projectile
Headroom requiredAbout 12 inches above the openingWorks in tight headroom
Suits heavy or insulated doorsYes — the standard choiceMarginal above about 130 lb
Upfront replacement cost$200 – $350$170 – $280 for the pair
Cost per 1,000 cyclesLowerHigher
Which system suits your doorChoose torsion when✓The door is double-width or insulated✓You have 12 inches of headroom✓The garage is used daily✓You want the quietest operation✓You are installing a new doorExtension still makes sense when✓Headroom is genuinely restricted✓The door is a light single panel✓Budget is the deciding factor✓Containment cables are fitted✓The existing hardware is sound
When each garage door spring system is the right choice

The cost-per-cycle line is the one that decides it for most London households. A torsion set costs roughly 25% more and lasts roughly 60% longer, and it takes the strain off the opener while it does so. On a door that runs 1,500 cycles a year, that difference compounds.

What spring replacement costs in London, Ontario

Prices below are 2026 ranges for the London area, parts and labour included, on a standard residential door.

2026 garage door spring replacement pricing — London, Ontario
JobTypical priceTime on site
Single torsion spring$200 – $35045 – 90 min
Both torsion springs (recommended)$300 – $48060 – 90 min
High-cycle torsion pair (25,000+)$400 – $62060 – 90 min
Extension springs, pair$170 – $28045 – 75 min
Extension springs + containment cables$210 – $33060 – 90 min
Convert extension to torsion$450 – $7502 – 3 hr
Spring replacement + cables + drums$400 – $65090 – 150 min

Always replace springs in pairs. On a two-spring door, both have done the same number of cycles and are the same age; replacing one leaves you paying a second call-out within a year or so, and an odd pair pulls the door out of balance in the meantime. This applies to extension springs absolutely and to torsion pairs almost as strongly. Our spring repair cost guide breaks the pricing down further, and how long garage door springs last covers cycle life in depth.

⚠ Spring work is not a DIY job — on either system

A residential torsion spring holds several hundred pounds of force and winding bars slip without warning. A stretched extension spring holds the same energy in a form that travels. Both need the correct winding bars, the correct vise grips on the track, and someone who has done it before. This is the one category of garage door work where the trade is unanimous: call a technician. Our spring repair service covers London and the surrounding area, same day.

One number to watch out for: a quote well under $150 for a torsion spring almost always means a builder-grade 10,000-cycle part, which you will be replacing again in six or seven years. Ask what cycle rating you are being quoted before you compare prices.

Is it worth converting extension springs to torsion?

It is a real option and we do a handful every month across London, but it is not automatically the right spend. The conversion means fitting a torsion shaft, bearing plates, cable drums and new cables above the opening, then removing the old springs and pulleys entirely. Budget $450 to $750, and around two to three hours.

It makes sense when:

  • You have at least 12 inches of headroom between the top of the opening and the ceiling. Without it, a standard conversion is not possible — though low-headroom torsion kits exist for tight spaces.
  • The door is heavy — a double, or an insulated door added to an older opening. Extension springs are marginal above roughly 130 lb.
  • The door is used constantly. Higher cycle life pays back faster the more the door runs.
  • The door tracks crooked and realignment keeps not lasting. Torsion forces both sides to move together, which cures the underlying cause.
  • You are replacing the door anyway. Nearly every new door installed in London goes in on torsion — see new door installation.

It is not worth it if the extension springs are healthy, the containment cables are fitted, headroom is tight, and the door is a light single that runs quietly. In that case the money is better spent on nylon rollers and fresh hinges, which will do more for how the door sounds and feels day to day.

What to expect on the day

A conversion is a two-technician job on most doors. The old springs and pulleys come off, the header gets a torsion shaft with bearing plates lagged into solid backing, new drums and cables are fitted, and the spring is wound to the door’s measured weight rather than a guess. The visit finishes with a balance test, a force and travel limit reset on the opener, and an auto-reverse safety test. If the opener has been fighting a heavy door for years, be prepared for the possibility that it is also near the end — our opener replacement guide covers that call.

Garage Door London handles spring work across London, Byron, Masonville, Lambeth and the surrounding communities, same day where we can. Request a flat-rate quote or call and we will tell you which system you have from a photo.

Free · no-obligation quote

Get a flat-rate price in minutes

Or call (226) 781-1003 · open 24/7 · same-day service

Frequently asked questions

Stand inside with the door closed and look up. A torsion spring sits on a steel shaft directly above the door opening. Extension springs are two thinner springs stretched along the horizontal tracks, one on each side, running back over where the car parks.

For most doors, yes. Torsion springs last 15,000 to 20,000 cycles against 8,000 to 10,000 for extension, run more quietly, force both sides of the door to move together, and are contained by the shaft when they fail. Extension springs cost less upfront and work where headroom is too tight for torsion.

A single torsion spring runs $200 to $350 installed, and a matched pair $300 to $480. High-cycle springs rated for 25,000 cycles or more cost $400 to $620 for the pair and roughly double the service life.

A pair of extension springs costs $170 to $280 installed in the London area. Adding the safety containment cables that should run through the centre of each spring brings it to $210 to $330. Extension springs are always replaced in pairs.

Yes. On a two-spring door both springs have done identical cycles and are the same age, so replacing one means a second call-out within a year and an unbalanced door in the meantime. The labour is already on site, so the incremental cost of the second spring is small.

No. A residential torsion spring holds several hundred pounds of force and winding bars can slip without warning; a stretched extension spring stores the same energy in a form that travels when it lets go. Spring work needs correct winding bars, proper track clamps and experience. This is the one job the whole trade agrees should be left to a technician.

A steel cable threaded through the centre of each extension spring and anchored at both ends. If the spring breaks, the cable holds the pieces in place instead of letting them fly across the garage. It is inexpensive, it is standard practice, and it is frequently missing on older London installations.

Often, yes. Conversion costs $450 to $750 and needs about 12 inches of headroom above the opening. It is worth it on heavy or insulated doors, doors used constantly, and doors that keep tracking crooked. It is not worth it on a light single door with healthy springs and containment cables already fitted.

Torsion springs typically give 10 to 15 years and extension springs 6 to 10, based on a household running about 1,500 cycles a year. Cold shortens that: steel becomes more brittle through London's freeze-thaw season, which is why spring failures cluster in January and February.

A single sharp bang, loud enough to be heard through the house and often mistaken for something falling. Afterwards the door is far too heavy to lift by hand and the opener will strain, hum or refuse to move it. Stop using the door and call for service — the opener is not built to lift an unsprung door.

What we put in writing

Three guarantees on every job

A fixed price before we start. The full price in writing after the diagnosis and before any work begins. Find something unexpected once the door is open and we stop and re-quote rather than adding it to your bill.

A written warranty. Lifetime on the parts we supply and five years on our labour, printed on the invoice rather than promised at the door.

A safety test before we leave. Balance, cables, drums, opener force and travel limits, and the auto-reverse tested against an obstruction — recorded on your invoice with the date.

torsion spring replacement London Ontarioextension spring replacement London Ontariotorsion vs extension garage door springsgarage door spring typesconvert extension springs to torsion London